116 productions played this house between 1918 and 2023.
116 in the catalogue.
| Information Please Selwyn Theatre | 1918 | 46 perf. |
| Buddies Selwyn Theatre | 1919 | 259 perf. |
| The Challenge Selwyn Theatre | 1919 | 72 perf. |
| Tumble In Selwyn Theatre | 1919 | 128 perf. |
| Tickle Me Selwyn Theatre | 1920 | 207 perf. |
| Snapshots of 1921 Selwyn Theatre | 1921 | 60 perf. |
| The Circle Selwyn Theatre | 1921 | 175 perf. |
| Partners Again Selwyn Theatre | 1922 | 250 perf. |
| The Blue Kitten Selwyn Theatre | 1922 | 140 perf. |
| Battling Buttler Selwyn Theatre | 1923 | 313 perf. |
| Dagmar Selwyn Theatre | 1923 | 56 perf. |
| Helen of Troy, New York Selwyn Theatre | 1923 | 191 perf. |
| The Guilty One Selwyn Theatre | 1923 | 31 perf. |
| Within Four Walls Selwyn Theatre | 1923 | 15 perf. |
| Charlot Revue Selwyn Theatre | 1925 | 138 perf. |
| Puppets Selwyn Theatre | 1925 | 54 perf. |
| The Sapphire Ring Selwyn Theatre | 1925 | 13 perf. |
| Two By Two Selwyn Theatre | 1925 | 16 perf. |
| Castles in the Air Selwyn Theatre | 1926 | 160 perf. |
| Fakir Rahman Bey Selwyn Theatre | 1926 | 24 perf. |
| The Constant Nymph Selwyn Theatre | 1926 | 148 perf. |
| The Man from Toronto Selwyn Theatre | 1926 | 28 perf. |
| Namiko-San Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 16 perf. |
| Nightstick Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 84 perf. |
| One Glorious Hour Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 20 perf. |
| The Garden of Eden Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 23 perf. |
| The Lady Screams Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 8 perf. |
| The Manhatters Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 68 perf. |
| The Mating Season Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 24 perf. |
| The Royal Family Selwyn Theatre | 1927 | 345 perf. |
| This Year of Grace Selwyn Theatre | 1928 | 157 perf. |
| Wake Up and Dream Selwyn Theatre | 1929 | 136 perf. |
| Lost Sheep Selwyn Theatre | 1930 | 96 perf. |
| Three’s a Crowd Selwyn Theatre | 1930 | 272 perf. |
| Fast Service Selwyn Theatre | 1931 | 7 perf. |
| The Singing Rabbi Selwyn Theatre | 1931 | 3 perf. |
| A Thousand Summers Selwyn Theatre | 1932 | 51 perf. |
| Electra Selwyn Theatre | 1932 | 6 perf. |
| Life Begins Selwyn Theatre | 1932 | 8 perf. |
| The Devil Passes Selwyn Theatre | 1932 | 96 perf. |
| The Great Magoo Selwyn Theatre | 1932 | 11 perf. |
| The Little Black Book Selwyn Theatre | 1932 | 8 perf. |
| Evensong Selwyn Theatre | 1933 | 15 perf. |
| Shooting Star Selwyn Theatre | 1933 | 16 perf. |
| A Hat, a Coat, a Glove Selwyn Theatre | 1934 | 13 perf. |
| Ragged Army Selwyn Theatre | 1934 | 2 perf. |
| The Respectful Prostitute Selwyn Theatre | 1949 | 272 perf. |
| Ladies Night in a Turkish Bath Selwyn Theatre | 1950 | 105 perf. |
| Betrayal American Airlines Theatre | 2000 | 89 perf. |
| The Man Who Came to Dinner American Airlines Theatre | 2000 | 85 perf. |
| Design For Living American Airlines Theatre | 2001 | 69 perf. |
| Major Barbara American Airlines Theatre | 2001 | 74 perf. |
| The Women American Airlines Theatre | 2001 | 77 perf. |
| An Almost Holy Picture American Airlines Theatre | 2002 | 69 perf. |
| An Evening With Mario Cantone American Airlines Theatre | 2002 | 4 perf. |
| The Boys from Syracuse American Airlines Theatre | 2002 | 73 perf. |
| The Man Who Had All the Luck American Airlines Theatre | 2002 | 62 perf. |
| A Day in the Death of Joe Egg American Airlines Theatre | 2003 | 69 perf. |
| As Long As We Both Shall Laugh American Airlines Theatre | 2003 | 15 perf. |
| Tartuffe American Airlines Theatre | 2003 | 53 perf. |