Never closed, on paper
An opening date, a substantial run, and no closing date at all. 212 productions, and 188 of them opened before 1950, so this is overwhelmingly a record-keeping absence rather than a show that never came off.
212 in the catalogue.
| Divorce Dalys Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1871 | 200 perf. |
| Too Much Johnson Standard Theatre | 1894 | 216 perf. |
| Trilby Garden Theatre | 1895 | 208 perf. |
| The Little Minister Empire Theatre | 1897 | 300 perf. |
| Sherlock Holmes Garrick Theatre | 1899 | 256 perf. |
| The Sultan of Sulu Wallacks Theatre | 1902 | 200 perf. |
| The Girl from Kay's Herald Square Theatre | 1903 | 231 perf. |
| The Music Master Belasco Theatre | 1904 | 627 perf. |
| The College Widow Garden Theatre | 1904 | 278 perf. |
| The Lion and the Mouse Lyceum Theatre | 1905 | 586 perf. |
| The Chorus Lady Savoy Theatre | 1906 | 315 perf. |
| The Road to Yesterday Herald Square Theatre | 1906 | 216 perf. |
| The Hypocrites Hudson Theatre | 1906 | 209 perf. |
| The Warrens of Virginia Belasco Theatre | 1907 | 380 perf. |
| The Thief Lyceum Theatre | 1907 | 281 perf. |
| The Witching Hour Hackett Theatre | 1907 | 212 perf. |
| A Gentleman from Mississippi Bijou Theatre | 1908 | 407 perf. |
| The Traveling Salesman Liberty Theatre | 1908 | 280 perf. |
| The Blue Mouse Lyric Theatre | 1908 | 232 perf. |
| The Fighting Hope Stuyvesant Theatre | 1908 | 231 perf. |
| A Trip to Japan Hippodrome Theatre | 1909 | 447 perf. |
| The Fortune Hunter Gaiety Theatre | 1909 | 345 perf. |
| The Climax Webers Music Hall | 1909 | 240 perf. |
| The Arcadians Liberty Theatre | 1910 | 201 perf. |
| The Quaker Girl Park Theatre | 1911 | 248 perf. |
| The Garden of Allah Century Theatre | 1911 | 241 perf. |
| Within the Law Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre | 1912 | 541 perf. |
| Seven Keys to Baldpate Astor Theatre | 1913 | 320 perf. |
| The Things That Count Maxine Elliotts Theatre | 1913 | 224 perf. |
| Under Cover Cort Theatre | 1914 | 349 perf. |
| Chin Chin Globe Theatre | 1914 | 295 perf. |
| Kitty Mackay Comedy Theatre | 1914 | 278 perf. |
| Daddy Long Legs Gaiety Theatre | 1914 | 264 perf. |
| Too Many Cooks 39th Street Theatre | 1914 | 223 perf. |
| A Pair of Silk Stockings Little Theatre | 1914 | 223 perf. |
| The Law of the Land 48th Street Theatre | 1914 | 221 perf. |
| A Pair of Sixes Longacre Theatre | 1914 | 207 perf. |
| The Dummy Hudson Theatre | 1914 | 200 perf. |
| The Boomerang Belasco Theatre | 1915 | 522 perf. |
| Fair and Warmer Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre | 1915 | 377 perf. |
| The Blue Paradise Casino Theatre | 1915 | 356 perf. |
| Hit-the-Trail-Holiday Astor Theatre | 1915 | 336 perf. |
| Sinners Playhouse Theatre | 1915 | 220 perf. |
| Treasure Island Punch And Judy Theatre | 1915 | 205 perf. |
| The Man Who Came Back Playhouse Theatre | 1916 | 457 perf. |
| Nothing But the Truth Longacre Theatre | 1916 | 332 perf. |
| The Thirteenth Chair 48th Street Theatre | 1916 | 328 perf. |
| Upstairs and Down Cort Theatre | 1916 | 320 perf. |
| Cheating Cheaters Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre | 1916 | 286 perf. |
| Come Out of the Kitchen George M Cohans Theatre | 1916 | 224 perf. |
| Eyes of Youth Maxine Elliotts Theatre | 1917 | 414 perf. |
| A Tailor-Made Man Cohan And Harris | 1917 | 398 perf. |
| Tiger Rose Lyceum Theatre | 1917 | 384 perf. |
| Polly With a Past Belasco Theatre | 1917 | 315 perf. |
| Parlor, Bedroom and Bath Theatre Republic | 1917 | 232 perf. |
| Hitchy-Koo Cohan & Harris Theatre | 1917 | 220 perf. |
| East is West Astor Theatre | 1918 | 680 perf. |
| Daddies Belasco Theatre | 1918 | 340 perf. |
| Three Wise Fools Criterion Theatre | 1918 | 316 perf. |
| Forever After Central Theatre | 1918 | 312 perf. |