The month Broadway actually starts. More productions have opened in October than in any other, and it is not close.
1,617 in the catalogue.
| The Merry Wives of Windsor John Street Theatre | 1789 | run not recorded |
| The Vision of the Sun Park Theatre | 1825 | run not recorded |
| Faustus Park Theatre | 1827 | run not recorded |
| Mathews At Home!/ The Comic Annual Park Theatre | 1834 | run not recorded |
| Amilie National Theatre | 1838 | run not recorded |
| 1940! Olympic Theatre | 1840 | 32 perf. |
| London Assurance Park Theatre | 1841 | run not recorded |
| Shylock Burtons Chambers Street Theatre | 1853 | 4 perf. |
| The Bohemian Girl Broadway Theatre | 1854 | run not recorded |
| Our American Cousin Laura Keenes Theatre | 1858 | run not recorded |
| The Bohemian Girl Burtons Chambers Street Theatre | 1858 | 4 perf. |
| Chamooni III Winter Garden Theatre | 1859 | run not recorded |
| Going it Blind Wallacks Lyceum Theatre | 1859 | 9 perf. |
| Les Noces De Jeannette Academy Of Music | 1861 | 1 perf. |
| Brother and Sister Olympic Theatre | 1863 | 9 perf. |
| Po-Ca-Hon-Tas Olympic Theatre | 1863 | 12 perf. |
| A Night in Rome New York Theatre | 1866 | 2 perf. |
| The Doctor of Alcantara New York Theatre | 1866 | 16 perf. |
| La Grande-Duchesse de Gérolstein Pikes Opera House | 1868 | 18 perf. |
| As You Like It Dalys Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1869 | run not recorded |
| Charles O'Malley Grand Opera House | 1869 | run not recorded |
| East Lynne Niblos Garden | 1869 | run not recorded |
| Flick Flock Woods Museum And Metropolitan | 1869 | 18 perf. |
| King Rene's Daughter Dalys Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1869 | run not recorded |
| Mary Warner Booths Theatre | 1869 | run not recorded |
| Oliver Twist Niblos Garden | 1869 | run not recorded |
| She Would and She Would Not Dalys Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1869 | run not recorded |
| The Heir-at-Law Wallacks Theatre | 1869 | run not recorded |
| The Streets of New York, or Poverty is No Crime Olympic Theatre | 1869 | run not recorded |
| Twelfth Night Dalys Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1869 | run not recorded |
| Humpty Dumpty Junior Woods Museum And Metropolitan | 1870 | 14 perf. |
| La Grande-Duchesse de Gérolstein Grand Opera House | 1870 | run not recorded |
| Little Nell and the Marchioness Niblos Garden | 1870 | 11 perf. |
| Lurline Woods Museum And Metropolitan | 1870 | 28 perf. |
| Two Roses Wallacks Theatre | 1870 | run not recorded |
| Wee Willie Winkie Olympic Theatre | 1870 | 132 perf. |
| Moorcroft Venue Name Unknown | 1874 | run not recorded |
| The Chimes of Normandy Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1877 | 16 perf. |
| French Flats Union Square Theatre | 1879 | run not recorded |
| Wives Dalys Theatre | 1879 | run not recorded |
| The Upper Crust Standard Theatre | 1880 | run not recorded |
| Friend and Foe Windsor Theatre | 1882 | 8 perf. |
| Ruth's Romance / Fourteen Days Union Square Theatre | 1882 | run not recorded |
| Young Mrs. Winthrop Madison Square Theatre | 1882 | run not recorded |
| Charles I Star Theatre | 1883 | run not recorded |
| Fedora Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | 1883 | run not recorded |
| La Jolie Parfumeuse Standard Theatre | 1883 | 1 perf. |
| Les Cloches De Corneville Standard Theatre | 1883 | 2 perf. |
| The Beggar Student Casino Theatre | 1883 | 110 perf. |
| Evangeline! Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | 1885 | 252 perf. |
| Nance Oldfield Grand Opera House | 1886 | run not recorded |
| Baron Rudolf Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | 1887 | run not recorded |
| A Brass Monkey Bijou Theatre | 1888 | run not recorded |
| Mr. Barnes of New York Broadway Theatre | 1888 | run not recorded |
| On the Frontier Windsor Theatre | 1888 | 8 perf. |
| One of the Old Stock Windsor Theatre | 1888 | 8 perf. |
| The Yeomen of the Guard Casino Theatre | 1888 | run not recorded |
| Our Flat Lyceum Theatre | 1889 | run not recorded |
| A Pair of Spectacles Madison Square Theatre | 1890 | run not recorded |
| Men and Women Proctors Theatre | 1890 | run not recorded |