A year and a day
Between 365 and 500 performances — a show that ran a solid year and then stopped. 256 productions, none of them remembered as a hit or a flop, which is the least written about outcome in the business.
256 in the catalogue.
| The Black Crook Theatre not recorded | 1866 | 474 perf. |
| Humpty Dumpty Olympic Theatre | 1868 | 483 perf. |
| Hazel Kirke Madison Square Theatre | 1880 | 486 perf. |
| 1492 Palmers Theatre | 1893 | 400 perf. |
| The Rose of the Rancho Belasco Theatre | 1906 | 480 perf. |
| The Merry Widow New Amsterdam Theatre | 1907 | 416 perf. |
| The Warrens of Virginia Belasco Theatre | 1907 | 380 perf. |
| The Man from Home Astor Theatre | 1908 | 496 perf. |
| Sporting Days Hippodrome Theatre | 1908 | 448 perf. |
| A Gentleman from Mississippi Bijou Theatre | 1908 | 407 perf. |
| A Trip to Japan Hippodrome Theatre | 1909 | 447 perf. |
| Get-Rich-Quick Wallingford Gaiety Theatre | 1910 | 424 perf. |
| Bought and Paid For Playhouse Theatre | 1911 | 476 perf. |
| Around the World Hippodrome Theatre | 1911 | 445 perf. |
| Under Many Flags Hippodrome Theatre | 1912 | 445 perf. |
| Twin Beds Fulton Theatre | 1914 | 411 perf. |
| On Trial Candler Theatre | 1914 | 365 perf. |
| Hip! Hip! Hooray! [1915] Hippodrome Theatre | 1915 | 425 perf. |
| Fair and Warmer Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre | 1915 | 377 perf. |
| The Man Who Came Back Playhouse Theatre | 1916 | 457 perf. |
| Turn to the Right! Gaiety Theatre | 1916 | 435 perf. |
| The Big Show Hippodrome Theatre | 1916 | 425 perf. |
| Maytime Shubert Theatre | 1917 | 492 perf. |
| Oh, Boy! Princess Theatre | 1917 | 463 perf. |
| Cheer Up Hippodrome Theatre | 1917 | 456 perf. |
| Eyes of Youth Maxine Elliotts Theatre | 1917 | 414 perf. |
| A Tailor-Made Man Cohan And Harris | 1917 | 398 perf. |
| Tiger Rose Lyceum Theatre | 1917 | 384 perf. |
| Everything Hippodrome | 1918 | 461 perf. |
| Sinbad Winter Garden | 1918 | 388 perf. |
| Happy Days Hippodrome Theatre | 1919 | 452 perf. |
| Good Times Hippodrome Theatre | 1920 | 456 perf. |
| Music Box Revue Music Box Theatre | 1921 | 440 perf. |
| Music Box Revue [1921] Music Box Theatre | 1921 | 440 perf. |
| Just Married Comedy Theatre | 1921 | 402 perf. |
| Get Together Hippodrome Theatre | 1921 | 397 perf. |
| Ziegfeld Follies of 1922 New Amsterdam Theatre | 1922 | 424 perf. |
| The Old Soak Plymouth Theatre | 1922 | 423 perf. |
| Better Times Hippodrome Theatre | 1922 | 405 perf. |
| Merton of the Movies Cort Theatre | 1922 | 392 perf. |
| Kid Boots Earl Carroll Theatre | 1923 | 489 perf. |
| Wildflower Casino Theatre | 1923 | 477 perf. |
| Little Jessie James Longacre Theatre | 1923 | 385 perf. |
| What Price Glory Plymouth Theatre | 1924 | 435 perf. |
| Desire Under the Elms Greenwich Village Theatre | 1924 | 420 perf. |
| They Knew What They Wanted Garrick Theatre | 1924 | 414 perf. |
| Cradle Snatchers Music Box Theatre | 1925 | 478 perf. |
| Artists and Models [1925] Winter Garden Theatre | 1925 | 416 perf. |
| The Last of Mrs. Cheyney Fulton Theatre | 1925 | 385 perf. |
| The Desert Song Casino Theatre | 1926 | 471 perf. |
| Lulu Belle Belasco Theatre | 1926 | 461 perf. |
| The Squall 48th Street Theatre | 1926 | 444 perf. |
| George White's Scandals [1926] Apollo Theatre | 1926 | 432 perf. |
| Sex Dalys 63rd Street Theatre | 1926 | 375 perf. |
| Queen High Ambassador Theatre | 1926 | 367 perf. |
| Rio Rita Ziegfeld Theatre | 1927 | 494 perf. |
| The Trial of Mary Dugan National Theatre | 1927 | 437 perf. |
| A Connecticut Yankee Vanderbilt Theatre | 1927 | 418 perf. |
| The Road to Rome Playhouse Theatre | 1927 | 392 perf. |
| Burlesque Plymouth Theatre | 1927 | 372 perf. |