A year and a day
Between 365 and 500 performances — a show that ran a solid year and then stopped. 256 productions, none of them remembered as a hit or a flop, which is the least written about outcome in the business.
256 in the catalogue.
| California Suite Eugene Oneill Theatre | 1976 | 445 perf. |
| Your Arms Too Short to Box With God Lyceum Theatre | 1976 | 429 perf. |
| The Runner Stumbles Little Theatre | 1976 | 396 perf. |
| My Fair Lady St James Theatre | 1976 | 377 perf. |
| Side by Side by Sondheim Music Box Theatre | 1977 | 384 perf. |
| On the Twentieth Century St. James Theatre | 1978 | 449 perf. |
| Eubie! Ambassador Theatre | 1978 | 439 perf. |
| Romantic Comedy Ethel Barrymore Theatre | 1979 | 396 perf. |
| 'night, Mother John Golden Theatre | 1983 | 380 perf. |
| Glengarry Glen Ross John Golden Theatre | 1984 | 378 perf. |
| Song and Dance Royale Theatre | 1985 | 474 perf. |
| The Search for Signs of Intelligent Life in the Universe Plymouth Theatre | 1985 | 391 perf. |
| Singin' in the Rain Gershwin Theatre | 1985 | 367 perf. |
| Social Security Ethel Barrymore Theatre | 1986 | 388 perf. |
| Sweet Charity Theatre not recorded | 1986 | 369 perf. |
| Jackie Mason's The World According to Me! Brooks Atkinson Theatre | 1986 | 367 perf. |
| The Nerd Helen Hayes Theatre | 1987 | 441 perf. |
| Burn This Plymouth Theatre | 1987 | 437 perf. |
| A Few Good Men Music Box Theatre | 1989 | 497 perf. |
| Lend Me a Tenor Royale Theatre | 1989 | 476 perf. |
| Six Degrees of Separation Vivian Beaumont Theater | 1990 | 485 perf. |
| Once on This Island Booth Theatre | 1990 | 469 perf. |
| Prelude to a Kiss Helen Hayes Theatre | 1990 | 440 perf. |
| Aspects of Love Broadhurst Theatre | 1990 | 377 perf. |
| Catskills on Broadway Lunt Fontanne Theatre | 1991 | 453 perf. |
| Dancing at Lughnasa Plymouth Theatre | 1991 | 421 perf. |
| Falsettos John Golden Theatre | 1992 | 486 perf. |
| Five Guys Named Moe Eugene O’Neill Theatre | 1992 | 445 perf. |
| Conversations With My Father Royale Theatre | 1992 | 402 perf. |
| Angels in America: Millennium Approaches Walter Kerr Theatre | 1993 | 367 perf. |
| An Inspector Calls Royale Theatre | 1994 | 454 perf. |
| The Life Ethel Barrymore Theatre | 1997 | 466 perf. |
| The Beauty Queen of Leenane Walter Kerr Theatre | 1998 | 365 perf. |
| Swing! St. James Theatre | 1999 | 461 perf. |
| The Rocky Horror Show Circle In The Square Theatre | 2000 | 437 perf. |
| Metamorphoses Circle In The Square Theatre | 2002 | 400 perf. |
| Oklahoma! Gershwin Theatre | 2002 | 388 perf. |
| The Graduate Plymouth Theatre | 2002 | 380 perf. |
| Wonderful Town Theatre not recorded | 2003 | 497 perf. |
| Golda's Balcony Helen Hayes Theatre | 2003 | 493 perf. |
| Gypsy Shubert Theatre | 2003 | 451 perf. |
| Little Shop of Horrors Virginia Theatre | 2003 | 372 perf. |
| Tarzan Richard Rodgers Theatre | 2006 | 486 perf. |
| Les Misérables Broadhurst Theatre | 2006 | 463 perf. |
| Young Frankenstein Hilton Theatre | 2007 | 485 perf. |
| Shrek the Musical Theatre not recorded | 2008 | 441 perf. |
| Fela! Eugene O’Neill Theatre | 2009 | 463 perf. |
| God of Carnage Bernard B Jacobs Theatre | 2009 | 452 perf. |
| A Little Night Music Walter Kerr Theatre | 2009 | 425 perf. |
| Million Dollar Quartet Nederlander Theatre | 2010 | 489 perf. |
| La Cage aux Folles Longacre Theatre | 2010 | 433 perf. |
| American Idiot St. James Theatre | 2010 | 422 perf. |
| How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying Al Hirschfeld Theatre | 2011 | 473 perf. |
| How to Succeed... (2011 Revival) Al Hirschfeld Theatre | 2011 | 473 perf. |
| Annie Palace Theatre | 2012 | 487 perf. |
| Nice Work If You Can Get It Imperial Theatre | 2012 | 478 perf. |
| If/Then Richard Rodgers Theatre | 2014 | 401 perf. |
| Cabaret Studio 54 | 2014 | 388 perf. |
| On the Town Lyric Theatre | 2014 | 368 perf. |
| The Color Purple Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre | 2015 | 493 perf. |