74 productions played this house between 1899 and 1996.
74 in the catalogue.
| Barbara Frietchie Criterion Theatre | 1899 | 83 perf. |
| The Girl from Maxim's Criterion Theatre | 1899 | 54 perf. |
| The Gay Lord Quex Criterion Theatre | 1900 | 67 perf. |
| The Pride of Jennico Criterion Theatre | 1900 | 111 perf. |
| A Royal Rival Criterion Theatre | 1901 | 112 perf. |
| Du Barry Criterion Theatre | 1901 | 165 perf. |
| Prince Charlie Criterion Theatre | 1901 | run not recorded |
| The Helmet of Navarre Criterion Theatre | 1901 | 24 perf. |
| When Knighthood Was in Flower Criterion Theatre | 1901 | 176 perf. |
| David Harum Criterion Theatre | 1902 | 16 perf. |
| Iris Criterion Theatre | 1902 | 77 perf. |
| The Cavalier Criterion Theatre | 1902 | 70 perf. |
| A Message from Mars Criterion Theatre | 1903 | 56 perf. |
| Lord and Lady Algy Criterion Theatre | 1903 | 16 perf. |
| The Jewel of Asia Criterion Theatre | 1903 | 64 perf. |
| The Little Princess Criterion Theatre | 1903 | 34 perf. |
| The Man from Blankley's Criterion Theatre | 1903 | 79 perf. |
| The Other Girl Criterion Theatre | 1903 | 160 perf. |
| A Wife Without a Smile Criterion Theatre | 1904 | 16 perf. |
| Business Is Business Criterion Theatre | 1904 | 57 perf. |
| The Dictator Criterion Theatre | 1904 | 64 perf. |
| The Light That Lies in Woman's Eyes Criterion Theatre | 1904 | 23 perf. |
| The Rich Mrs. Repton Criterion Theatre | 1904 | 5 perf. |
| The Second Fiddle Criterion Theatre | 1904 | 32 perf. |
| The Triumph of Love Criterion Theatre | 1904 | 1 perf. |
| Cousin Billy Criterion Theatre | 1905 | 76 perf. |
| Her Great Match Criterion Theatre | 1905 | 93 perf. |
| Jinny, the Carrier Criterion Theatre | 1905 | 21 perf. |
| Nancy Stair Criterion Theatre | 1905 | 29 perf. |
| On the Quiet Criterion Theatre | 1905 | 16 perf. |
| Pantaloon / Alice Sit-by-the-Fire Criterion Theatre | 1905 | 81 perf. |
| The Little Cherub Criterion Theatre | 1906 | 176 perf. |
| The Little Father of the Wilderness/The Mountain Climber Criterion Theatre | 1906 | 24 perf. |
| The Mountain Climber Criterion Theatre | 1906 | 55 perf. |
| Miss Hook of Holland Criterion Theatre | 1907 | 119 perf. |
| The Dairymaids Criterion Theatre | 1907 | 86 perf. |
| The Morals of Marcus Criterion Theatre | 1907 | 44 perf. |
| The Tattooed Man Criterion Theatre | 1907 | 59 perf. |
| The Truth Criterion Theatre | 1907 | 34 perf. |
| Fluffy Ruffles Criterion Theatre | 1908 | 48 perf. |
| Samson Criterion Theatre | 1908 | 152 perf. |
| An Englishman's Home Criterion Theatre | 1909 | 40 perf. |
| The Flag Lieutenant Criterion Theatre | 1909 | 24 perf. |
| The Outpost Criterion Theatre | 1909 | run not recorded |
| The Richest Girl Criterion Theatre | 1909 | 24 perf. |
| The Commuters Criterion Theatre | 1910 | 160 perf. |
| Sire Criterion Theatre | 1911 | 31 perf. |
| The Girl of My Dreams Criterion Theatre | 1911 | 40 perf. |
| The Happiest Night of His Life Criterion Theatre | 1911 | 24 perf. |
| Chains Criterion Theatre | 1912 | 1 perf. |
| Tantalizing Tommy Criterion Theatre | 1912 | 31 perf. |
| The Girl from Montmartre Criterion Theatre | 1912 | 72 perf. |
| The Grain of Dust Criterion Theatre | 1912 | 24 perf. |
| What Ails You? Criterion Theatre | 1912 | 24 perf. |
| White Magic Criterion Theatre | 1912 | 21 perf. |
| Indian Summer Criterion Theatre | 1913 | 24 perf. |
| Young Wisdom Criterion Theatre | 1914 | 56 perf. |
| Major Pendennis Criterion Theatre | 1916 | 75 perf. |
| Paganini Criterion Theatre | 1916 | 48 perf. |
| Anthony in Wonderland Criterion Theatre | 1917 | 7 perf. |