61 productions played this house between 1866 and 1914.
61 in the catalogue.
| A Night in Rome New York Theatre | 1866 | 2 perf. |
| Cendrillon New York Theatre | 1866 | 36 perf. |
| Griffith Gaunt New York Theatre | 1866 | run not recorded |
| The Doctor of Alcantara New York Theatre | 1866 | 16 perf. |
| A Bird of Paradise New York Theatre | 1867 | 15 perf. |
| Kenilworth New York Theatre | 1867 | 12 perf. |
| Paris and Helen New York Theatre | 1868 | 65 perf. |
| The Grand Duchess of Gérolstein New York Theatre | 1868 | 33 perf. |
| In Gay Paree New York Theatre | 1899 | 48 perf. |
| The Man in the Moon New York Theatre | 1899 | 192 perf. |
| A Million Dollars New York Theatre | 1900 | 28 perf. |
| Broadway to Tokio New York Theatre | 1900 | 88 perf. |
| Nell-Go-In New York Theatre | 1900 | 25 perf. |
| The Giddy Throng New York Theatre | 1900 | 164 perf. |
| The King's Carnival New York Theatre | 1901 | 64 perf. |
| King Highball New York Theatre | 1902 | 33 perf. |
| The Chaperons New York Theatre | 1902 | 60 perf. |
| The Hall of Fame New York Theatre | 1902 | 137 perf. |
| When Johnny Comes Marching Home New York Theatre | 1902 | 71 perf. |
| Ben Hur New York Theatre | 1903 | 96 perf. |
| Dorothy Vernon of Haddon Hall New York Theatre | 1903 | 40 perf. |
| In Dahomey New York Theatre | 1903 | 53 perf. |
| Home Folks New York Theatre | 1904 | 34 perf. |
| Terence New York Theatre | 1904 | 56 perf. |
| The Maid and the Mummy New York Theatre | 1904 | 42 perf. |
| The Southerners New York Theatre | 1904 | 36 perf. |
| The Tenderfoot New York Theatre | 1904 | 81 perf. |
| Woodland New York Theatre | 1904 | 100 perf. |
| Hamlet New York Theatre | 1905 | 1 perf. |
| Little Johnny Jones New York Theatre | 1905 | run not recorded |
| The Ham Tree New York Theatre | 1905 | 90 perf. |
| The Mayor of Tokio New York Theatre | 1905 | 50 perf. |
| Eileen Asthore New York Theatre | 1906 | 16 perf. |
| His Honor the Mayor New York Theatre | 1906 | 104 perf. |
| Humpty Dumpty New York Theatre | 1906 | 24 perf. |
| Mrs. Wiggs of the Cabbage Patch New York Theatre | 1906 | 24 perf. |
| The Ham Tree New York Theatre | 1906 | 40 perf. |
| George Washington, Jr. New York Theatre | 1907 | 40 perf. |
| The Land of Nod and The Song Birds New York Theatre | 1907 | 17 perf. |
| The Squaw Man New York Theatre | 1907 | 8 perf. |
| The Vanderbilt Cup New York Theatre | 1907 | 48 perf. |
| Cohan and Harris Minstrels [1908] New York Theatre | 1908 | 32 perf. |
| Mary's Lamb New York Theatre | 1908 | 80 perf. |
| Miss Innocence New York Theatre | 1908 | 176 perf. |
| The American Idea New York Theatre | 1908 | 64 perf. |
| The Soul Kiss New York Theatre | 1908 | 122 perf. |
| Cohan and Harris Minstrels [1909] New York Theatre | 1909 | 16 perf. |
| Miss Innocence New York Theatre | 1909 | 16 perf. |
| The Man Who Owns Broadway New York Theatre | 1909 | 128 perf. |
| The Sins of Society New York Theatre | 1909 | 31 perf. |
| A Skylark New York Theatre | 1910 | 24 perf. |
| Bright Eyes New York Theatre | 1910 | 48 perf. |
| Naughty Marietta New York Theatre | 1910 | 136 perf. |
| The Deacon and the Lady New York Theatre | 1910 | 16 perf. |
| The Merry Whirl New York Theatre | 1910 | 24 perf. |
| The Young Turk New York Theatre | 1910 | 32 perf. |
| Jumping Jupiter New York Theatre | 1911 | 24 perf. |
| The Enchantress New York Theatre | 1911 | 112 perf. |
| The Pearl Maiden New York Theatre | 1912 | 24 perf. |
| Big Jim Garrity New York Theatre | 1914 | 27 perf. |