208 productions opened on the 24th, 25th or 26th of December. A Christmas Carol did it repeatedly and on purpose. Most of the rest were chasing a holiday audience that had nowhere else to be.
208 in the catalogue.
| Needs Must John Street Theatre | 1793 | run not recorded |
| Monte Cristo Broadway Theatre | 1848 | run not recorded |
| King Charming Broadway Theatre | 1855 | 34 perf. |
| Po-Ca-Hon-Tas Wallacks Lyceum Theatre | 1855 | run not recorded |
| Hiawatha Wallacks Lyceum Theatre | 1856 | 24 perf. |
| The Ring of Fate Barnums American Museum | 1864 | 40 perf. |
| Barbe-Bleue Grand Opera House | 1870 | run not recorded |
| The Mother's Secret Union Square Theatre | 1877 | run not recorded |
| The Man of Success Union Square Theatre | 1877 | run not recorded |
| Olivette Bijou Theatre | 1880 | 108 perf. |
| Paul Kauvar Standard Theatre | 1887 | run not recorded |
| Carmen Empire Theatre | 1895 | run not recorded |
| Courted Into Court Bijou Theatre | 1896 | 140 perf. |
| The Sorrows of Satan Broadway Theatre | 1898 | run not recorded |
| A Female Drummer Star Theatre | 1898 | 56 perf. |
| Phroso Empire Theatre | 1898 | run not recorded |
| Remember the Maine Peoples Theatre | 1898 | run not recorded |
| The Little Host Herald Square Theatre | 1898 | 37 perf. |
| My Lady's Lord Empire Theatre | 1899 | 25 perf. |
| The Beggar Student American Theatre | 1899 | 9 perf. |
| The Bowery After Dark Star Theatre | 1899 | run not recorded |
| The Cowboy and the Lady Knickerbocker Theatre | 1899 | 44 perf. |
| Three Little Lambs Fifth Avenue Theatre | 1899 | 49 perf. |
| A Royal Rogue Broadway Theatre | 1900 | 30 perf. |
| The Giddy Throng New York Theatre | 1900 | 164 perf. |
| The House That Jack Built Hoyts Theatre | 1900 | 18 perf. |
| The Village Postmaster Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | 1900 | 16 perf. |
| Miss Prinnt Victoria Theatre | 1900 | 28 perf. |
| Du Barry Criterion Theatre | 1901 | 165 perf. |
| The Girl with the Green Eyes Savoy Theatre | 1902 | 108 perf. |
| Lady Teazle Casino Theatre | 1904 | 57 perf. |
| Common Sense Bracket Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | 1904 | 24 perf. |
| Home Folks New York Theatre | 1904 | 34 perf. |
| In Newport Liberty Theatre | 1904 | 24 perf. |
| Me, Him and I West End Theatre | 1904 | 24 perf. |
| The House of Burnside Princess Theatre | 1904 | run not recorded |
| The Little Minister Empire Theatre | 1904 | 73 perf. |
| The Winter's Tale Knickerbocker Theatre | 1904 | 32 perf. |
| As Ye Sow Garden Theatre | 1905 | 34 perf. |
| Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary Garrick Theatre | 1905 | 14 perf. |
| Mlle. Modiste Knickerbocker Theatre | 1905 | 202 perf. |
| Pantaloon / Alice Sit-by-the-Fire Criterion Theatre | 1905 | 81 perf. |
| The Babes and the Baron Lyric Theatre | 1905 | 45 perf. |
| A Broken Man's Promise Haverlys 14th Street Theatre | 1906 | run not recorded |
| Dream City Webers Music Hall | 1906 | 102 perf. |
| Peter Pan Empire Theatre | 1906 | 40 perf. |
| The Magic Knight Webers Music Hall | 1906 | 102 perf. |
| The Student King Garden Theatre | 1906 | 40 perf. |
| Her Sister Hudson Theatre | 1907 | 61 perf. |
| Under the Greenwood Tree Garrick Theatre | 1907 | 44 perf. |
| Judas Globe Theatre | 1910 | run not recorded |
| Phèdre Globe Theatre | 1910 | run not recorded |
| La Samaritaine Globe Theatre | 1910 | run not recorded |
| The Spring Maid Liberty Theatre | 1910 | 208 perf. |
| Kismet Knickerbocker Theatre | 1911 | 184 perf. |
| The Wedding Trip Broadway Theatre | 1911 | 48 perf. |
| The Land of Promise Lyceum Theatre | 1913 | 76 perf. |
| The Lie Harris Theatre | 1914 | 172 perf. |
| To-Night's the Night Shubert Theatre | 1914 | 112 perf. |
| Hello, Broadway! Astor Theatre | 1914 | 123 perf. |