Older than the show they belong to
These shows have a production listed that opened before the show was written. Gypsy has stagings from 1903 and 1929, decades before the 1959 musical, because two different works ended up filed under the same title. We show both and mark them rather than picking one.
119 in the catalogue.
| Our Town | 2024 | earliest staging 1938 |
| Over Here! | 1974 | earliest staging 1918 |
| Parade | 1998 | earliest staging 1935 |
| Paris | 1928 | earliest staging 1869 |
| Passion | 1994 | earliest staging 1983 |
| Patriots | 2024 | earliest staging 1913 |
| Peter Pan | 1954 | earliest staging 1905 |
| Pickwick | 1965 | earliest staging 1927 |
| Pins And Needles | 1937 | earliest staging 1922 |
| Pippin | 1972 | earliest staging 1870 |
| Proof | 2026 | earliest staging 2000 |
| Robin Hood | 1891 | earliest staging 1872 |
| Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella | 2013 | earliest staging 1855 |
| Rosalie | 1928 | earliest staging 1917 |
| Seventeen | 1951 | earliest staging 1918 |
| Seventh Heaven | 1955 | earliest staging 1922 |
| Shenandoah | 1975 | earliest staging 1889 |
| Sinbad | 1918 | earliest staging 1905 |
| Sister Act | 2011 | earliest staging 2009 |
| Song and Dance | 1985 | earliest staging 1982 |
| Sophie | 1963 | earliest staging 1920 |
| South Pacific | 1949 | earliest staging 1943 |
| Starlight Express | 1987 | earliest staging 1984 |
| Street Scene | 1947 | earliest staging 1929 |
| Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | 1979 | earliest staging 1924 |
| Sweet Charity | 1966 | earliest staging 1942 |
| Tammy Faye | 2024 | earliest staging 2022 |
| The Body Beautiful | 1958 | earliest staging 1935 |
| The Boy Friend | 1954 | earliest staging 1932 |
| The Cat And The Fiddle | 1931 | earliest staging 1907 |
| The Consul | 1950 | earliest staging 1903 |
| The Firefly | 1912 | earliest staging 1869 |
| The Gay Life | 1961 | earliest staging 1909 |
| The Grand Tour | 1979 | earliest staging 1951 |
| The Great Gatsby | 2024 | earliest staging 1926 |
| The Green Pastures | 1951 | earliest staging 1930 |
| The Happy Time | 1968 | earliest staging 1950 |
| The Liar | 1950 | earliest staging 1896 |
| The New Yorkers | 1930 | earliest staging 1901 |
| The Phantom of the Opera | 1988 | earliest staging 1986 |
| The Picture of Dorian Gray | 2025 | earliest staging 2024 |
| The Pirates Of Penzance | 1981 | earliest staging 1879 |
| The Robber Bridegroom | 1976 | earliest staging 1975 |
| The Rocky Horror Show | 2026 | earliest staging 1973 |
| The Three Musketeers | 1928 | earliest staging 1921 |
| The Visit | 2015 | earliest staging 1958 |
| The Wild Rose | 1926 | earliest staging 1902 |
| Thoroughly Modern Millie | 2002 | earliest staging 1956 |
| Tommy | 1993 | earliest staging 1927 |
| Two By Two | 1970 | earliest staging 1925 |
| Two Gentlemen of Verona | 1971 | earliest staging 1958 |
| Uncle Vanya | 2024 | earliest staging 1923 |
| Violet | 2014 | earliest staging 1944 |
| Waiting for Godot | 2025 | earliest staging 1955 |
| Wake Up and Dream | 1929 | earliest staging 1928 |
| WANTED | 2026 | earliest staging 1928 |
| Wonderland | 2011 | earliest staging 1905 |
| You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown | 1999 | earliest staging 1967 |
| Young Frankenstein | 2007 | earliest staging 2006 |