Runs past 2,000 performances
Runs of 2,000 performances or more. Phantom of the Opera gave 13,981. The Lion King has passed ten thousand and is still going.
39 in the catalogue.
| Abie's Irish Rose Fulton Theatre | 1922 | 2,327 perf. |
| Tobacco Road Theatre Masque | 1933 | 3,182 perf. |
| Life With Father Empire Theatre | 1939 | 3,224 perf. |
| Oklahoma! St. James Theatre | 1943 | 2,212 perf. |
| My Fair Lady Mark Hellinger Theatre | 1956 | 2,717 perf. |
| Fiddler on the Roof Imperial Theatre | 1964 | 3,242 perf. |
| Hello, Dolly! St. James Theatre | 1964 | 2,844 perf. |
| Man of La Mancha ANTA Washington Square Theatre | 1965 | 2,328 perf. |
| Grease Eden Theatre | 1972 | 3,388 perf. |
| Gease Eden Theatre | 1972 | 3,388 perf. |
| A Chorus Line Shubert Theatre | 1975 | 6,137 perf. |
| Oh! Calcutta! Edison Theatre | 1976 | 5,959 perf. |
| Annie Alvin Theatre | 1977 | 2,377 perf. |
| 42nd Street Majestic Theatre | 1980 | 3,486 perf. |
| Cats Winter Garden Theatre | 1982 | 7,485 perf. |
| Les Miserables Broadway Theatre | 1987 | 6,680 perf. |
| Les Misérables Broadway Theatre | 1987 | 6,680 perf. |
| The Phantom of the Opera Majestic Theatre | 1988 | 13,981 perf. |
| Miss Saigon Broadway Theatre | 1991 | 4,092 perf. |
| Beauty and the Beast Palace Theatre | 1994 | 5,461 perf. |
| Smokey Joe's Cafe Theatre not recorded | 1995 | 2,036 perf. |
| Chicago Richard Rodgers Theatre | 1996 | 9,999 perf. |
| Rent Nederlander Theatre | 1996 | 5,123 perf. |
| The Lion King New Amsterdam Theatre | 1997 | 10,000 perf. |
| Cabaret Kit Kat Klub at Studio 54 | 1998 | 2,377 perf. |
| Mamma Mia ! Winter Garden Theatre | 2001 | 5,758 perf. |
| The Producers St. James Theatre | 2001 | 2,502 perf. |
| Hairspray Neil Simon Theatre | 2002 | 2,642 perf. |
| Wicked Gershwin Theatre | 2003 | 8,500 perf. |
| Avenue Q John Golden Theatre | 2003 | 2,534 perf. |
| Jersey Boys August Wilson Theatre | 2005 | 4,642 perf. |
| Mary Poppins New Amsterdam Theatre | 2006 | 2,619 perf. |
| Rock of Ages Brooks Atkinson Theatre | 2009 | 2,328 perf. |
| The Book of Mormon Eugene O'Neill Theatre | 2011 | 5,000 perf. |
| Kinky Boots Al Hirschfeld Theatre | 2013 | 2,505 perf. |
| Aladdin New Amsterdam Theatre | 2014 | 9,999 perf. |
| Beautiful: The Carole King Musical Stephen Sondheim Theatre | 2014 | 2,418 perf. |
| Hamilton Richard Rodgers Theatre | 2015 | 3,500 perf. |
| Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Lyric Theatre | 2018 | 2,231 perf. |