Staged, but not on Broadway
Every production of these shows played somewhere the catalogue does not classify as a Broadway house — off Broadway, the West End, or a building it has not yet identified. 83 of them.
83 in the catalogue.
| The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | 2005 | Musical |
| The Band Visit | 2017 | Musical |
| The Black Crook | 1866 | Musical |
| The Boy from Oz | 2003 | Musical |
| The Bridges of Madison County | 2014 | Musical |
| The Broken Date | 1958 | Musical |
| The Firefly | 1912 | Musical |
| The Girl in the Pink Tights | 1954 | Musical |
| The Golden Apple | 1954 | Musical |
| The Lost Boys | 2026 | Musical |
| The Pirate Queen | 2007 | Musical |
| The Prom | 2018 | Musical |
| The Scottsboro Boys | 2010 | Musical |
| The Will Rogers Follies | 1991 | Musical |
| tick, tick... BOOM! | 2001 | Musical |
| Tootsie | 2019 | Musical |
| Torch Song Trilogy | 1982 | Musical |
| Truckload | 1975 | Musical |
| War Paint | 2017 | Musical |
| What Makes Sammy Run? | 1964 | Musical |
| Whistle Down the Wind | 1996 | Musical |
| Woman of the Year | 1981 | Musical |
| Young Frankenstein | 2007 | Musical |