Heaven and the devil
Old Devil Moon. Heaven on Earth. Thank the Lord the War Is Over. City Called Heaven. 33 shows reach for the religious register, most of them entirely secularly.
33 in the catalogue.
| Avenue Q | 2003 | Musical |
| Chess | 1988 | Musical |
| Chess | 2025 | Revival |
| Come from Away | 2017 | Musical |
| Don’t Bother Me, I Can’t Cope | 1972 | Musical |
| Fiddler on the Roof | 1964 | Musical |
| Finian’s Rainbow | 1947 | Musical |
| Godspell | 1976 | Musical |
| Greenwillow | 1960 | Musical |
| Hadestown | 2019 | Musical |
| Happy Town | 1959 | Musical |
| High Spirits | 1964 | Musical |
| Hooray For What! | 1937 | Musical |
| I Married an Angel | 1938 | Musical |
| Jersey Boys | 2005 | Musical |
| Jesus Christ Superstar | 1971 | Musical |
| Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat | 1982 | Musical |
| Louisiana Purchase | 1940 | Musical |
| Memphis | 2009 | Musical |
| Miss Saigon | 1991 | Musical |
| Music in the Air | 1932 | Musical |
| Oh Captain! | 1958 | Musical |
| Oh, Kay! | 1926 | Musical |
| Once on This Island | 1990 | Musical |
| Portofino | 1958 | Musical |
| Rock of Ages | 2009 | Musical |
| Shinbone Alley | 1957 | Musical |
| Shuffle Along | 1921 | Musical |
| The Chocolate Soldier | 1909 | Musical |
| The Color Purple | 2005 | Musical |
| The Golden Apple | 1954 | Musical |
| The King and I | 1951 | Musical |
| The Scarlet Pimpernel | 1997 | Musical |