Starring Christian Borle
10 shows across 26 years, 1998 to 2024. Taken from the cast list of each staging, so every one is a production they were actually in.
10 in the catalogue.
| Footloose Richard Rodgers Theatre | 1998 | 709 perf. |
| Thoroughly Modern Millie Marquis Theatre | 2002 | 903 perf. |
| Spamalot Shubert Theatre | 2005 | 1,575 perf. |
| Mary Poppins New Amsterdam Theatre | 2006 | 2,619 perf. |
| Legally Blonde Palace Theatre | 2007 | 595 perf. |
| Peter and the Starcatcher Brooks Atkinson Theatre | 2012 | 319 perf. |
| Something Rotten! Theatre not recorded | 2015 | 742 perf. |
| Falsettos Walter Kerr Theatre | 2016 | 85 perf. |
| Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Lunt-Fontanne Theatre | 2017 | 305 perf. |
| Tammy Faye Palace Theatre | 2024 | 29 perf. |