Seats unknown
29 theatres in the catalogue with no seat count recorded. Most of them are gone — the Standard, the Manhattan, the Theatre Comique — and the number went with the building.
29 in the catalogue.
| Madison Square Theatre | 1863–1908 | 12 productions |
| Theatre Comique | 1869–1881 | 4 productions |
| Manhattan Theatre | 1875–1909 | 55 productions |
| Standard Theatre | 1875–1909 | 20 productions |
| Daly's Theatre | 1879–1920 | 1 productions |
| Wallack's Theatre | 1882–1915 | 1 productions |
| New York Theatre | 1895–1913 | 61 productions |
| Manhattan Opera House | 1906–1939 | 40 productions |
| Jardin de Paris | 1907–1925 | 6 productions |
| Gaiety Theatre | 1908–1943 | 43 productions |
| Cohan & Harris Theatre | 1911–1938 | 2 productions |
| 44th Street Theatre | 1912–1945 | 87 productions |
| 63rd St. Music Hall | 1914–1971 | 1 productions |
| Greenwich Village Theatre | 1917–1930 | 58 productions |
| Nora Bayes Theatre | 1918–1945 | 53 productions |
| Jolson Theatre | 1921–1932 | 2 productions |
| Ritz Theatre | 1921–1982 | 99 productions |
| Holiday Theatre | 1923–1955 | 6 productions |
| Coronet Theatre | 1925–1959 | 32 productions |
| Eden Theatre | 1926–1977 | 4 productions |
| Gallo Theatre | 1927–1976 | 1 productions |
| Edison Theatre | 1931–1991 | 14 productions |
| Windsor Theatre | 1937–1959 | 31 productions |
| Theatre de Lys | 1952–1981 | 1 productions |
| Entermedia Theatre | 1961–1989 | 1 productions |
| ANTA Washington Square Theatre | 1964–1969 | 7 productions |
| Theatre 80 St. Marks | 1964 | 1 productions |
| Roundabout Theatre | 1965 | 1 productions |
| Jane Street Theatre | 1996 |