Revivals that outran the original
Revivals that ran longer than the original. Chicago managed 936 performances in 1975 and 9,999 when it came back. Candide ran 73 nights in 1956 and returned for 740.
68 in the catalogue.
| A Bronx Tale | 2016 | 111 → 700 |
| A Family Affair | 1962 | 6 → 65 |
| Aida | 2000 | 1 → 1,852 |
| An Enemy of the People | 2024 | 1 → 127 |
| Anastasia | 2017 | 272 → 808 |
| Anything Goes | 1934 | 420 → 784 |
| Arms and the Girl | 1950 | 77 → 134 |
| Betsy | 1926 | 32 → 39 |
| Bright Star | 2016 | 7 → 114 |
| Cabaret | 1966 | 1,165 → 2,377 |
| Candide | 1956 | 8 → 740 |
| Carnival! | 1961 | 13 → 719 |
| Catch Me If You Can | 2011 | 103 → 170 |
| Chicago | 1975 | 172 → 9,999 |
| Diana | 2021 | 8 → 33 |
| Fallen Angels | 2026 | 36 → 239 |
| Fanny | 1954 | 63 → 888 |
| Footloose | 1998 | 32 → 709 |
| Galileo | 2026 | 6 → 76 |
| Gentlemen Prefer Blondes | 1949 | 199 → 740 |
| Golden Boy | 1964 | 250 → 569 |
| Grand Hotel | 1989 | 459 → 1,077 |
| Gypsy | 1959 | 1 → 702 |
| Head Over Heels | 2018 | 100 → 188 |
| Kismet | 1953 | 184 → 583 |
| Lorelei | 1974 | 7 → 320 |
| Maurice Chevalier | 1955 | 18 → 46 |
| Merrily We Roll Along | 1981 | 155 → 352 |
| No, No, Nanette | 1925 | 321 → 861 |
| On Your Toes | 1936 | 315 → 505 |
| Over Here! | 1974 | 23 → 341 |
| Pal Joey | 1940 | 374 → 540 |
| Parade | 1998 | 40 → 169 |
| Paris | 1928 | 12 → 195 |
| Passion | 1994 | 97 → 280 |
| Peter Pan | 1954 | 223 → 554 |
| Pins And Needles | 1937 | 46 → 1,108 |
| Pippin | 1972 | 28 → 1,944 |
| Porgy and Bess | 1935 | 124 → 322 |
| Robin Hood | 1891 | 22 → 105 |
| She Loves Me | 1963 | 301 → 354 |
| Shenandoah | 1975 | 250 → 1,050 |
| Show Boat | 1927 | 572 → 947 |
| Sinbad | 1918 | 9 → 388 |
| South Pacific | 1949 | 5 → 1,925 |
| Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | 1979 | 67 → 188 |
| Sweet Charity | 1966 | 8 → 608 |
| Sweethearts | 1913 | 136 → 288 |
| The Body Beautiful | 1958 | 4 → 60 |
| The Boy Friend | 1954 | 15 → 485 |
| The Cat And The Fiddle | 1931 | 8 → 395 |
| The Consul | 1950 | 24 → 269 |
| The Firefly | 1912 | 14 → 120 |
| The Fortune Teller | 1898 | 40 → 68 |
| The Gay Life | 1961 | 8 → 113 |
| The Grand Tour | 1979 | 8 → 61 |
| The New Yorkers | 1930 | 64 → 168 |
| The Red Mill | 1906 | 274 → 531 |
| The Robber Bridegroom | 1976 | 14 → 145 |
| The Rocky Horror Show | 2026 | 45 → 437 |