Demolished, dark, or gone
49 of the theatres in this catalogue are no longer open. Niblo's Garden, where The Black Crook ran in 1866. The Hippodrome, which seated 5,300. Every one of them has productions attached and no building to attach them to.
49 in the catalogue.
| Theatre 80 St. Marks | 1964 | 1 productions |
| Theatre Comique | 1869–1881 | 4 productions |
| Niblo's Garden 3,200 seats | 1823–1895 | |
| Madison Square Theatre | 1863–1908 | 12 productions |
| Manhattan Theatre | 1875–1909 | 55 productions |
| Standard Theatre | 1875–1909 | 20 productions |
| New York Theatre | 1895–1913 | 61 productions |
| Wallack's Theatre | 1882–1915 | 1 productions |
| Daly's Theatre | 1879–1920 | 1 productions |
| Jardin de Paris | 1907–1925 | 6 productions |
| Casino Theatre 1,300 seats | 1882–1930 | 108 productions |
| Greenwich Village Theatre | 1917–1930 | 58 productions |
| Knickerbocker Theatre 1,300 seats | 1893–1930 | 162 productions |
| Jolson Theatre | 1921–1932 | 2 productions |
| Liberty Theatre 1,077 seats | 1904–1933 | 88 productions |
| Times Square Theatre 1,057 seats | 1920–1933 | 39 productions |
| Cohan & Harris Theatre | 1911–1938 | 2 productions |
| Hippodrome 5,300 seats | 1905–1939 | 2 productions |
| Manhattan Opera House | 1906–1939 | 40 productions |
| Vanderbilt Theatre 771 seats | 1918–1939 | 73 productions |
| Gaiety Theatre | 1908–1943 | 43 productions |
| 44th Street Theatre | 1912–1945 | 87 productions |
| Nora Bayes Theatre | 1918–1945 | 53 productions |
| Center Theatre 3,700 seats | 1932–1954 | 58 productions |
| 48th Street Theatre 969 seats | 1912–1955 | 135 productions |
| Central Theatre 922 seats | 1918–1955 | 11 productions |
| Holiday Theatre | 1923–1955 | 6 productions |
| Princess Theatre 299 seats | 1913–1955 | 115 productions |
| Astor Theatre 1,100 seats | 1906–1959 | 43 productions |
| Coronet Theatre | 1925–1959 | 32 productions |
| Hammerstein's Theatre 1,500 seats | 1927–1959 | 3 productions |
| Maxine Elliott's Theatre 924 seats | 1908–1959 | 1 productions |
| Windsor Theatre | 1937–1959 | 31 productions |
| New Century Theatre 1,700 seats | 1921–1962 | 94 productions |
| Ziegfeld Theatre 1,638 seats | 1927–1966 | 40 productions |
| ANTA Washington Square Theatre | 1964–1969 | 7 productions |
| 63rd St. Music Hall | 1914–1971 | 1 productions |
| Gallo Theatre | 1927–1976 | 1 productions |
| Eden Theatre | 1926–1977 | 4 productions |
| Theatre de Lys | 1952–1981 | 1 productions |
| Bijou Theatre 612 seats | 1917–1982 | 179 productions |
| Fulton Theatre 1,100 seats | 1911–1982 | 118 productions |
| Morosco Theatre 1,009 seats | 1917–1982 | 167 productions |
| Ritz Theatre | 1921–1982 | 99 productions |
| Entermedia Theatre | 1961–1989 | 1 productions |
| Mark Hellinger Theatre 1,603 seats | 1930–1989 | 62 productions |
| Earl Carroll Theatre 3,000 seats | 1922–1990 | 20 productions |
| Edison Theatre | 1931–1991 | 14 productions |
| Henry Miller's Theatre 1,055 seats | 1918–2004 | 1 productions |